Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Doug Israel's avatar

What the colleges are saying (Or at least NYU whose policy I read) is that the use of the word Zionist instead of Jew will not inoculate the speaker from being charged with anti-semitic hate speech if applicable. One can argue whether hate speech should be prohibited by universities but if it is going to be, Jew haters should not have the loophole of substituting the word Zionist for Jew.

Regarding what is going to happen, every single student participating in an illegal protest should be expelled. Period. They can be given advance warning that this will happen. That will end the protests very quickly. But I cant imagine the school administrations doing this.

Expand full comment
Nachum / Ned's avatar

There is nothing wrong with the word, ‘Zionist’ just like there is nothing wrong with the word, ‘Jew’ and nothing wrong with saying Asians have slanted eyes. But there is something wrong with saying, “you are all a bunch of Zionists, the way you all behave,” or “hey look at that Jew,” or “ hey, slanty eyes, yeah I’m talking to you.”

It is often less the word used than the context it is used in and whether the intent is discriminatory or defamatory.

Expand full comment

No posts